Let's keep things simple and jump straight to it. We've got a list below of the best places in Greater Mystic, organized by a few convenient categories. Save this page, as we'll update it frequently.

1. BREAKFAST RESTAURANTS

Toast + Tonic: Start your morning with creative, farm-fresh breakfast dishes at this beloved Mystic spot.

Flour Shop Bagels: Enjoy hand-rolled bagels and gourmet spreads, made fresh daily in Pawcatuck (Mystic's neighbor).

Noah's: Known for its homemade pastries and hearty breakfasts, this cozy eatery in the quaint Stonington Borough is a local favorite.

Indulge: Also located in Stonington, Indulge offers decadent breakfast classics with a modern twist, perfect for starting the day right.

Lighthouse Bakery: A hidden gem offering delectable treats, breakfast sandwiches, and Illy coffee in a charming setting in the heart of downtown Mystic. Patio seating available in the warmer months!

Carson's: Carson's Store in Noank is a beloved local gem. Originally a general store (in 1907), Carson’s has transformed into a cafe serving up classic diner fare, homemade ice cream, and nostalgic charm in a cozy, seaside setting.

 

2. LUNCH RESTAURANTS

Popover Eatery: Delight in creative comfort food and artisan popovers at this charming breakfast/lunch destination (their lattes are incredible).

Milestone: Fresh, locally sourced ingredients shine on a vibrant, seasonal menu at Milestone, located on Water Street in Mystic.

Boost Bowls: As the name implies, this is THE spot for bowls, including acai, as well as smoothies, sandwiches, salads, and wraps. 

Friar Tuck's Tavern: A lively spot serving classic pub fare and craft brews in a welcoming atmosphere. You can expect to watch the game on the TVs above their bar!

Mystic Market: Explore gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads, housemade desserts, and more at this upscale deli market.

Karma Kitchen: Savor flavorful, plant-based dishes—and smoothies, juices and smoothie bowls—that are as delicious as they are nourishing.

Off The Hook: From the team behind J&R Seafood Market, Off The Hook offers fresh, innovative seafood dishes perfect for dining on the go — featuring favorites like lobster roll flights and poke bowls in the heart of downtown Mystic.

 

3. DINNER RESTAURANTS

Photo by Lisa Nichols/Bread & Beast Food Photography

Bravo Bravo: Indulge in upscale Italian cuisine paired with an excellent wine list in this intimate setting.

S&P Oyster: Dine on fresh seafood with stunning views of the Mystic River at this iconic waterfront spot.

Whitecrest Eatery: Experience a modern take on global cuisine with a focus on sustainable ingredients, located in Stonington's iconic Velvet Mill.

Red 36: Relax by the water and watch the boats go by as you enjoy creative seafood dishes in a stylish, open-air setting.

Engine Room: This industrial-chic eatery offers juicy burgers, craft beers, and an unmatched whiskey and bourbon selection in a laid-back atmosphere.

Water Street Cafe: Discover elevated New England fare and an extensive wine selection at this classic restaurant, located in the heart of the quaint Stonington Borough.

Oyster Club: Farm-to-table dining shines at this rustic-chic destination for fresh, locally sourced meals by chef Renee Touponce, 2x James Beard Award Finalist.

Bleu Ginger: A stylish fusion spot in Mystic, serving up fresh, flavorful Japanese and Vietnamese cuisine, from sushi and pho to creative specialty rolls.

Pearl: A stylish waterfront restaurant offering fresh, locally inspired seafood dishes and craft cocktails in a relaxed yet elegant setting.

Shipwright's Daughter: An award-winning restaurant in downtown Mystic, known for its innovative, seasonally driven menu celebrating New England’s coastal flavors.

Palmer's: A casual neighborhood spot serving up hearty comfort food, fresh seafood, and delicious pizza with a welcoming, laid-back vibe.

Captain Daniel Packer Inne (DPI): Step into history and savor classic New England cuisine in this 250-year-old inn, where 18th century restored fireplaces and warm hospitality have welcomed travelers for generations. (Don’t miss the pub downstairs—details in the “BARS” section!)

La Plage: One of the newest restaurants in Mystic and certainly among the most elegant, La Plage blends the finest coastal flavors with innovative cuisine. The restaurant is located inside Delamar Mystic on the grounds of Mystic Seaport Museum. 

 

4. PIZZA

Photo by Klara Kulikova on Unsplash

Mystic Pizza: A "slice of heaven" made famous by Hollywood (and Julia Roberts' breakout role!) serving legendary pies since 1973.

Angie's Pizza: A local favorite for classic Italian pies, wraps, paninis, fresh seafood, and homestyle comfort.

Palmer's Provisions and Pizza: Elevated artisan pizza meets gourmet provisions in the heart of historic Noank Village. Don't miss their desserts!

Nana's Mystic: Sourdough pizza perfection, where farm-fresh ingredients and natural fermentation shine.

Back Door Pizza: Don't miss this hidden gem in Stonington at The Historic Velvet Mill. Back Door offers wood-fired sourdough pizza at its finest.

 

5. BAKERIES

Sift Bakery: Famous for its award-winning pastries and breathtaking rooftop views of downtown Mystic.

Zest Fresh Pastry Bakery: Enjoy artisanal pastries and desserts made with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients.

Nana's Bakery: Celebrate the art of baking with sourdough pizzas, pastries, and local coffee.

Lis Bake Shop: Treat yourself to small-batch, handmade baked goods in this cozy downtown bakery.

 

6. SEASONAL RESTAURANTS

Haring's: An 'elevated clam shack' on Noank’s historic waterfront, Haring’s serves locally sourced seafood, a raw bar, and lobster rolls. Arrive by boat or land and enjoy fresh flavors from the team behind 85th Day Food Community.

Costello's: A casual, covered outdoor spot just down the road from Haring’s, Costello’s Clam Shack is perfect for fried seafood, fish tacos, and steamed lobsters—all with a front-row view of passing boats.

Abbott's: A Noank staple since 1947, Abbott’s Lobster is famous for its hot buttered lobster rolls, steamers, and oysters on the half shell—best enjoyed with a waterfront breeze.

Sea Swirl: A classic roadside seafood stand serving up crispy fried clams, lobster rolls, and soft-serve ice cream—perfect for a casual bite by the water.

Sea View Snack Bar: Enjoy fresh seafood with stunning waterfront views—lobster rolls, clam fritters, and more—all served from this no-frills, seasonal shack.

7. BARS

The Port of Call: Named one of Esquire’s Best Bars in America, this nautical-inspired cocktail bar offers award-winning beverages and uniquely delicious dishes (think: squid ink empanadas) in the heart of downtown Mystic.

Dive Bar: Downstairs from The Port of Call, this below-deck watering hole channels the spirit of deep-sea exploration. Sip a cold beer, play shuffleboard or vintage arcade games, and keep an eye out for karaoke nights and special events.

Misfit Club: A welcoming bar serving up craft beer and good vibes for its community of "nonconformists and merrymakers." Check their calendar for weekly events like team trivia, Bingo, artist nights, and more!

Harp & Hound: A charming Irish pub tucked away downtown, serving up pints of Guinness, hearty comfort food, and warm hospitality.

DPI Pub: Grab a spot by the fireplace in this historic maritime tavern, where hearty pub fare, craft drinks, and live music create a lively, welcoming atmosphere by the Mystic River.

Chapter One: A lively bar and restaurant with craft cocktails, elevated pub fare, and weekend nightlife in the heart of downtown Mystic.

8. WINERIES

Jonathan Edwards Winery: Nestled in the rolling hills of North Stonington, Jonathan Edwards Winery offers award-winning wines in a picturesque setting, complete with a cozy tasting room and stunning vineyard views.

Saltwater Farm Vineyard: Set on a former World War II-era airstrip, Saltwater Farm Vineyards combines historic charm with exceptional wines, offering a unique tasting experience with panoramic views of the surrounding landscape.

Kingdom of the Hawk: A stunning destination in North Stonington, Kingdom of the Hawk offers exceptional wines and breathtaking vineyard views from its contemporary barn, blending modern architecture with the area’s agricultural heritage.

9. HEALTH & FITNESS

Hot on Bank Mystic: With spaces in Mystic and New London, Hot on Bank offers heated and non-heated vinyasa yoga classes, including early morning sunrise hours!

Mystic Yoga Shala: Offering Baptiste-style heated and non-heated vinyasa yoga, this serene studio overlooks the idyllic Mystic coastline, creating the perfect space for movement and mindfulness.

Ocean Community YMCA: More than just a fitness center, this YMCA offers group classes and programs for all ages in a welcoming space with stunning Mystic Harbor views—plus access to Williams Beach for a unique waterfront experience.

Seaport Pilates: A boutique pilates studio in Mystic specializing in personalized, small-group training to enhance strength, mobility, and overall wellness.

Vita Vigor Wellness: Founded with a vision to help people integrate various types of movement into their lifestyle, this Stonington Borough-based studio offers yoga, dance, and strength-training classes.

 

10. SPAS

Le Spa: Where beauty meets expertise. Indulge in luxurious facials, rejuvenating body treatments, and expert skincare in the heart of Mystic.

Cerulean Spa: Immerse yourself in coastal tranquility with holistic therapies, soothing massages, and personalized wellness treatments. Located at the Mystic Marriott Hotel.

Cure Med Spa: A one-stop destination for all your beauty and wellness needs. Indulge in cutting-edge aesthetic medicine while nourishing your mind, body, and soul in luxurious treatment rooms.

11. BRANDS & RETAIL STORES

Just Mystic: Shop unique Mystic-inspired gifts, home decor, and apparel in this coastal-modern boutique.

Adore: Find trendy, chic clothing and accessories that reflect the heart of Mystic.

RI Boutique: Discover contemporary styles and must-have seasonal fashion in this local favorite. Locations in Mystic and Watch Hill.

Rochelle's: Browse a carefully curated selection of on-trend clothing, jewelry, and accessories.

Fat Face: This UK-based brand offers stylish, casual apparel perfect for a Mystic getaway.

Mystic Knotwork: Explore handcrafted nautical gifts and decor at this iconic Mystic store.

Malloves Jewelers: A trusted jeweler in Mystic, specializing in timeless designs and custom creations.

Blue Horse: Beautiful items for children, including special occasion, christening, and matching outfits.

 

12. GIFT SHOPS

Trove: Discover one-of-a-kind treasures, from artisan crafts to unique gifts for all occasions.

La Cote: Shop luxury items and coastal-inspired decor at this upscale boutique.

Queenies Gift Emporium: Find whimsical, heartfelt gifts that delight shoppers of all ages.

Hang The Moon: Explore eclectic gifts and vintage-inspired goods at this charming shop.

Spencer & Lynn: A boutique bottle shop & liquor store in the heart of downtown Mystic.

Mountain Hollow: This shop offers a curated selection of unique gifts, home decor, and artisan goods, blending rustic charm with modern elegance in the heart of Mystic.

 

13. THRIFT/ANTIQUE SHOPS 

Stonington COMO Thrift Shop: Browse antiques and vintage finds in this unique waterfront marketplace.

Fun and Funky Vintage: Shop retro treasures and quirky collectibles for a truly nostalgic experience. Located in the Velvet Mill in Stonington.

Pennywise: Unearth hidden gems and affordable antiques at this local favorite consignment shop.

Grand & Water Antiques: Discover timeless pieces and historic artifacts curated with care.

Femme & Nest: Shop delightful vintage clothes for many bodies (XXS-5X+), home goods & more. Queer femme owned and IG sales on Fridays!

 

14. MARKETS

J&R Seafood Market: Founded by local fishermen, this family-run market brings fresh, high-quality seafood straight from the source to Mystic. Shop for locally caught fish, house-made chowders, seafood spreads, and more—plus a made-to-order menu for a delicious bite on the go.

The Ditty Bag: A zero-waste, sustainable market near the Mystic train station, offering bulk cereals, dried fruits, nuts, grains, teas, and spices—plus eco-friendly essentials like shampoo and conditioner bars.

Seawell Seafood: A no frills, fresh-off-the-boat market serving up high quality seafood, prepared dishes, and raw bar items. Locations in Mystic and Pawcatuck!

Mystic Market: A beloved gourmet deli and café, known for its fresh-made sandwiches, prepared meals, specialty desserts, and artisanal groceries.

 

15. SALONS & BARBER SHOPS

Rob Rivers Salon & Spa: A full-service salon and spa in downtown Mystic, offering expert cuts, color, and luxurious spa treatments in an elegant, relaxing setting.

Crop Hair Studio: A modern, eco-conscious salon specializing in lived-in color, precision cuts, and effortless, low-maintenance styles.

Antonio Hair Design: A classic barbershop and salon whose staff possess decades of experience, known for its skilled styling and welcoming, old-school charm.

Salon Golden: A boutique salon where artistry meets haircare, offering personalized cuts, color, and styling in a bright, inviting space.

 

16. LANDMARKS/ATTRACTIONS

Mystic Seaport Museum: Step into the past at this renowned living history museum and maritime village.

Mystic Noank Library: A historic community hub offering a vast collection of books, programs, and events in a charming 19th-century building. 

Marquis Jewelry Academy: Part artisan jeweler, part hands-on studio, this Mystic gem offers custom-crafted jewelry and workshops where you can create your own one-of-a-kind pieces.

Mystic Aquarium: Explore marine life wonders and hands-on exhibits at this top-rated family destination.

The Stonington LightHouse Museum: Explore this unique and historic lighthouse, built in 1840, for a dose of history and stunning views of Long Island Sound.

Mystic River Bascule Bridge: Watch the iconic drawbridge (the oldest bascule bridge in the US still in operation today) in action while taking in views of downtown Mystic.

Nathaniel B. Palmer House Visit the beautifully preserved home of legendary Antarctic explorers and brothers Nathaniel and Alexander Palmer.

 

17. SEASONAL ACTIVITIES

Argia Cruises: Sail away on scenic cruises showcasing the best of Mystic’s coastal beauty.

Tree Trail Adventures: Embark on outdoor fun with zip lines and tree-top obstacle courses for all ages.

Seaside Shadows Haunted History Tours: Uncover Mystic’s eerie past with these captivating ghost tours.

Sound Sails: This group creates magic in the waves with private charters and sunset sails.

 

18. HOTELS

Delamar Mystic: 31 distinctive rooms & suites with floor-to-ceiling windows showcasing breathtaking views of Mystic River and Mystic Seaport Museum. Also on property is La Plage, a refined waterfront dining experience. 

Harbor View Landing: A waterfront retreat featuring private cottages and suites with stunning views of the Mystic River, perfect for a peaceful and luxurious escape.

The Whaler’s Inn: A premier boutique hotel in downtown Mystic, just steps from the river and the iconic Bascule Drawbridge, offering award-winning hospitality and home to the acclaimed Shipwright’s Daughter restaurant.

Captain's Mansion: A meticulously restored historic mansion offering refined hospitality, white-glove service, and an intimate eight-room experience in the heart of Mystic.

Steamboat Inn: An elegant 11-room waterfront inn in downtown Mystic, offering stunning river views and seasonal transient dockage for those arriving by boat.

Taber Inn: A charming, family-owned inn with 12 buildings set on two manicured acres, just a short walk from Nana’s, one of Esquire’s Best New Restaurants in America.

The Inn at Mystic & Haley Mansion: Set on 14 scenic acres overlooking Fishers Island Sound, this inn offers ocean-view rooms, jacuzzis, fireplaces, and full-service events at the historic Haley Mansion.

 

19. AIRBNBs

Photo via The Wallasey Airbnb Page

The Wallasey: One of the newest guest properties in Mystic is also one of the most sophisticated. Accommodating up to 14 guests, this beautiful historic home is right next to The Historic Captain Daniel Packer Inne and steps from all the action.

20. HIKING SPOTS

Check out this guide on AllTrails for Greater Mystic's best hiking spots.